the Daily Bruin

A minority within the LGBT community

 
By SONALI KOHLI
Published November 16, 2011, 1:19 am in News A Closer Look
  Email this article  |        Share on Delicious  Share on Digg
Tools
web.11.15.cl.transgender

Fifth-year Asian American studies student Ryth Mendez identifies as genderqueer. Mendez faces challenges both on and off campus but has never reported it for fear of other people misunderstanding or retaliation.

web.11.15.cl.transgender.picb

Ryth Mendez is genderqueer who works to increase acceptance of this identity.

Possibly Related

Editor’s Note: Throughout this article, Ryth Mendez is referred to by the gender pronouns “they” or “their.” Mendez, who is genderqueer and does not identify as only male or female, prefers these pronouns to “he” or “she.” For Mendez, “they” encompasses multiple genders.

Ryth Mendez doesn’t identify as just male or just female.

Mendez prefers “they” instead of gender pronouns, and goes by “Ryth” instead of “Ruth,” their birth name, to discourage people from gendering them right away.

Mendez is genderqueer, which the fifth-year Asian American studies student defines for themself as embodying all genders.

Mendez identifies as part of the transgender community, though Mendez doesn’t feel that they were assigned the wrong gender at birth, or want to use surgery and hormones to pass as a certain gender.

“I can’t completely be defined as male or female,” Mendez said. “I feel like it’s not enough for me.”

Mendez’s openness about their identity has exposed them to hurtful experiences, though, both on campus and off. Last month, while Mendez was eating in a restaurant on Sawtelle Boulevard, a group of people at a nearby table snickered and commented on Mendez’s leg hair, Mendez said.

Mendez wanted to respond but was afraid of a negative reaction, they said. Mendez has heard stories from friends and seen media reports about transphobic crimes, though Mendez has never been physically attacked.

Mendez’s gender assigned at birth was female and their voice is more identifiable as female because of the higher pitch, but Mendez does not identify solely with either gender and doesn’t feel the need to shave their legs, they said.

“I try my best to ignore it,” Mendez said. “If I could I would stick up for myself, but I’m afraid of the violent aspect. Even if that person is alone, I fear the reaction.”

On campus, Mendez has faced insensitive comments from passersby and overheard people calling them a “tranny” even in the Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender Resource Center, Mendez said.

But Mendez didn’t report these instances to university police, the LGBT Center or the Office of the Dean of Students because they didn’t want to be misunderstood or face retaliation, Mendez said.

This is a common reaction from members of the LGBT community who face harassment, said Queer Alliance director Marcus McRae, a fourth-year linguistics and anthropology and political science student.

There are usually between one and three LGBT-related incidents reported to UCPD annually, said UCPD spokeswoman Nancy Greenstein. She said she could not remember any that involved transgender individuals.

Within the Office of the Dean of Students, there has been one bias report filed and one student conduct case filed related to sexual orientation in 2011, according to an email from Dean of Students Robert Naples. They were not transgender-related, Naples said.

Verbal bashing is traditionally underreported and can be as damaging as physical violence, said Peter Carley, the counselor in residence for the LGBT center. People become used to the taunts growing up and are almost desensitized, Carley said.

As a counselor he can encourage students to report incidents, but many feel the same fears as Mendez and don’t. The jabs, however, continue to take a toll on people, Carley said.

“Everybody’s looking for a box to fit everything into, but each person is their own box,” Carley said.

Transgender students are even more vulnerable at times than other members of the LGBT community, Carley said.

For example, it’s difficult to decide which gender bathroom to use, since they could be unwelcome in both, he said.

Mendez prefers private or gender-neutral bathrooms, but they can be difficult to find on campus. Mendez said they fear a hate crime happening in a bathroom because of lack of surveillance.

Mendez uses women’s bathrooms if forced to choose, because Mendez fears retaliation from men more than from women, they said.

Sometimes in public bathrooms on campus, other students will open the door, see Mendez and leave, either unsure if they are in the right restroom or uncomfortable with Mendez’s presence, Mendez said.

If someone is staring and seems unsure about whether Mendez belongs there, Mendez will let out a slight cough so the person will hear the tone of their voice and gender Mendez as female.

“People gender me as soon as they hear me,” Mendez said.

The presence of a gender binary in society affects Mendez in other daily activities, too. On Facebook, Mendez left the “male or female” spot blank. Health care providers and teachers assume Mendez is female.

Mendez shops for clothes in both the men’s and the women’s sections but wishes there were a clothing line encompassing all genders.

Mendez came out as genderqueer last year – before that Mendez identified as a lesbian woman. Mendez said most of their friends were accepting and supportive but that it was much easier to come out as lesbian than it was to come out as genderqueer.

Mendez has faced resistance from other transgender people who have transitioned from male to female and believe it isn’t possible to encompass both genders.

Mendez has defended themself in on-campus arguments and online attacks on their blog, sometimes leading to bouts of depression that Mendez has battled with a counselor from Counseling and Psychological Services.

People have grown up with a gender binary, so they are not used to thinking about calling someone “he” or “she,” Mendez said. Through outreach, panels and regional conferences, Mendez is able to explain the concept of being genderqueer to more people, but explaining that the preferred gender pronoun is “they” can be awkward to bring up in a casual conversation, Mendez said.

“People still want to call me ‘she,’” Mendez said. “It’s like I’m coming out all the time.”

If people are unsure how Mendez identifies themself, Mendez prefers that they just ask. It would require a shift in the way people think to always ask someone their preferred gender upon first meeting them, but Mendez thinks it’s possible to achieve and might make others who are questioning or transitioning feel more comfortable coming out.

The LGBT center is also involved in increasing acceptance of transgender people on campus, said Raja Bhattar, the center’s director.

They honor members of the transgender community who have experienced violence or death through hate crimes annually through the Transgender Day of Remembrance.

The center also holds events and sends students to programs such as “T-camp” in January, which will bring together transgender, genderqueer and gender non-conforming students from 20 universities, Bhattar said.

Today, transgender youth who modeled for the 2012 Calender of “Angels of Change” will speak at the center about their experiences.

Small victories are encouraging to Mendez, they said. Mendez plans on taking a course next quarter on transgender issues, and when enrolling, Mendez was excited to see that more than one person had signed up.

But Mendez still has reminders of their status as a minority within a minority.

Standing in the LGBT center, Mendez scanned a patchwork of LGBT artwork on the wall, searching the squares of colorful paper covered with inspirational messages and pictures of pride from LGBT people and their families.

Among the rainbow hearts and “LGBT Pride” proclamations, Mendez couldn’t find a single transgender flag or symbol.


Join the discussion

You Should Know: Any comments posted on dailybruin.com may be printed in the Daily Bruin. the Daily Bruin reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.

If this is the first time you've commented, your comment won't appear until you've verified your email address.

Formatting Options:
  • Links: "my link":http://my.url.com
  • Bold: *something!*
  • Italic: _OMG!_

2 comments

As another genderqueer, I have a big problem with the context of the “genderqueer” identity under the “transgender” umbrella. The goals of genderqueer and transgender people are fundamentally different, and by couching arguments about genderqueer issues as transgender issues, Mendez is undermining fundamentally what sets genderqueers and transgenders apart. Genderqueers want to be able to embrace all gendered behaviors regardless of biological sex or societal expectations of gendered performance, but by and large the transgenders want to fit into one gendered category that is the opposite of the biological sex they were assigned. The crux of the genderqueer identity is that gender is not mandatory and should not be enforced. This is different from the transgender identity where gender is powerfully self-enforced, and physical changes are necessary in order to achieve congruence between the mind’s gender and the physical body. By trying to combine these two radically different ideas, genderqueers are only obfuscating their own goals about gender identity. For the real genderqueer movement to get off the ground, we have to distance ourselves from the transgender community, and make it known that what we embody is the dissolution of the gender binary, the idea that as humans we have to gendered at all.

12:07 PM November 16, 2011, by The Great Elsewhere
Flag this comment

I apologize in advance for any mistakes, English is not my first language. I’m a bigender individual which means I am sometimes a male and sometimes a female, but at different times. It’s different from being a crossdresser or a transgender and I am not sick with split personalities (sadly some people think this). I was born as a female named Kateryna and I still keep my given name when female and I still have my female body. When I identify as male my name is Katriel (which is male name in Hebrew). Usually I prefer to just get called Kat since it’s short for either. Being bigender is both a external and internal change for me, externally I will change my looks, the way I talk and walk and my mannerisms, internally I will also go through this change and have the mentality of either a man or a woman depending on the situation or on a day to day bases. Sometimes this shift is done consciously (as in, I think about it and do it on purpose) but it’s usually just something that happens without ever thinking on it. Some bigender people get top or bottom surgery to accomodate there gender identities but I am not going to do this. The way my body is now, I am flat enough for no binding when I’m male which I am thankful for. If I had any surgery I would look too much one way or the other which I don’t want. As with how people are born straight/gay/bisexual/pansexual/transgender/just male/just female/everywhere in between, I am born bigender. I started showing signs of going between both genders from as early as 3 according to my mother, but consciously as age 4 I chopped off all my hair and started dressing more like the boys and then putting on a wig and wearing feminine clothes on days I felt more girly. Unfortunately that’s also when the abuse started both at school and at home, kids and there parents were really confused by me. Like the article, even something like using a bathroom was hard, the girls wouldn’t want me in the girls room and the boys wouldn’t want me in the boys room, I was called “sexless” by some kids. There were days where everyone made it too hard to go to the bathroom at all and I would have to wait until home. My father also didn’t want “his little girl pretending to be a little boy.” Eventually my mother took me and my sister and we moved to a different city and we lived there until the end of high school. My father was no longer in the picture but the bullying at school was still very hard and I will always remember. I’ve lived in Canada for a little over th past 5 years now and things are much different here. Unlike in Ukraine there is a much bigger LGBT community, it doesn’t feel like so many people have to hide. I haven’t met anyone who is bigender but I have met several genderqueer individuals who I am proud to call good friends. I also met my partner Nakita who was from Russia, we have been together for almost 3 years. I have a job as hotel desk clerk and am lucky that I haven’t had many worries with my co employees there, alot of them have been very understanding and willing to learn. I do still have run ins with people where they tell me they think bigender is “nonsense” and that it’s all “psychological problems” that I have. This will always hurt especially since I try to tell them about me and offer learning resources, but there will always be people who insult because they don’t understand and they don’t want to educate themselves to become better. I feel sad for these people that they will never go outside of there view of gender identity (or sexual identity/orientation), or what they view as “normal” because there ignorance will lead to such a closed and boring life. So I would like to say to anyone out there who may not fit the “gender binary” or may not be “gender normative” that you were meant to be this way, you are perfect. There will always be people who give you trouble, it’s because they don’t understand. But you can have a great life and they’ll be the ones with a narrow view and boring existence

4:10 PM February 10, 2012, by Kat
Flag this comment
Advertisement
Featured classifieds »

ADLER WEINER RESEARCH is conducting a study with Male Juniors and Seniors This is a 2 part Study. You will be paid $25 for an 1-2 min video. Some people will be chosen for a follow-up interview on Friday, June 8th, which will pay $75 for 30 min. PLEASE EMAIL awfocusgroups@gmail.com WITH THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION...1. NAME2. AGE3. ETHNICITY4. WHAT YEAR ARE YOU IN? 5. PLEASE LIST WHAT YOU DO TO WORKOUT. 6. BEST DAY TIME TELEPHONE NUMBER!!! WE ARE ALSO ACCEPTING REFERRALS IF YOU HAVE FRIENDS THAT MIGHT QUALIFY, PLEASE PASS ALONG THIS INFORMATION. · 2200 - Research Subjects


CLINICAL RESEARCH COORDINATOR/MAXILLOFACIAL: Performing research on maxillofacial pain, Tempromandibular jaw dysfunction, atypical tooth pains, Atypical facial& headaches, bruxism, stress related jaw pains. Collect data, Identify protocol problems, inform investigators& assists in problem resolution efforts. Review patients record to find new treatment methods. Review proposed study protocols to evaluate factors, data management plans& potential subject risks. Send resume to: M.Heikali; F&M Radiology Medical Center Inc., 18065 Ventura Blvd, Encino, CA 91316 · 2200 - Research Subjects


C AND C++ INSTRUCTOR. SEEKING AN INTERN who is good at C and C++ coding. Ability to understand pre-written codes and explain to non-technical audience. Please specify the course/experience you had. The position will be all through summer and may be extended. The hours can be flexible. We pay $20 - 70/hr depends on experience. pls send your CV at yjpark09_1999@yahoo.com · 7800 - Help Wanted


CSO OFFICE ASSISTANTOffice Assistant needed to work flexible hours at the UCLA Police Dept./CSO Programs. Earn $9.37/hr. Must be a UCLA student w/at least one YR. remaining. Training provided for clerical duties. For details call (310) 825-5064. · 7800 - Help Wanted


RECEPTIONIST/SECRETARYWestside law firm seeking receptionist/secretary. Mon.- Fri. from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Ability to type from dictation and office experience not required, but preferred. Email resume with cover letter to joycparker@yahoo.com with title law office receptionist. · 7800 - Help Wanted


***For Sale- Luxury Condo 2B/2B 90024 - Close to UCLA www.decoratorcondo.com · 8750 - Condo/Townhouse for Sale

More multimedia »