the Daily Bruin

In the know: Occupy Oakland violence

 
By NICOLE MIREA
Published January 30, 2012, 11:52 pm in Opinion Columns, Opinion
  Email this article  |        Share on Delicious  Share on Digg
Tools
Possibly Related

Oakland police arrested more than 400 Occupy Oakland members who attempted to break into Oakland City Hall, as well as the city’s downtown YMCA building and unused Henry Kaiser Convention Center Saturday afternoon in a protest that involved violence from both sides.

While the Oakland Police Department did not deny its use of smoke, tear gas and non-lethal bullets, it maintained that officers only did so after issuing multiple warnings to the protestors who had begun destroying construction equipment and fencing surrounding the Kaiser center.

“Officers were pelted with bottles, metal pipe, rocks, spray cans, improvised explosive devices and burning flares,” according to a statement from Oakland Police Department, released after the use of smoke and tear gas.

So was Occupy Oakland’s Move-In Day a wise idea?

On Dec. 21, the Occupy Oakland General Assembly passed a proposal to occupy and hold a large building for purposes of organization and shelter. And thus, Move-In Day was born.

Since this large-scale protest was coordinated through the Internet, it is clear that Occupy Oakland is already pretty organized despite the lack of an indoor meeting space. And if shelter was the Occupiers’ primary concern, they could have negotiated peacefully through the proper channels. If the city really had “no plans for use” of the Kaiser center (as Occupy Oakland claimed), there would be no reason to withhold it from those who respectfully asked for it for a legitimate purpose.

Thus, the seizure of the community center – and the subsequent arrest of more than 400 protestors – was unnecessary. It may have even been detrimental to the Occupiers’ cause.

The Occupy movement, which represents a broad expression of frustration with economic inequality, targeted at the United State’s richest citizens, seems to have lost its footing recently.

As of yet, no national political change has been affected as a result of the protests. At best, the Occupiers have managed to annoy local authorities to the point of exasperation and foot the cities they occupy with a steep bill – as Jean Quan, mayor of Oakland, can attest after estimating Occupy protests’ total damages since October to be $2 million.

So why haven’t they been more effective?

One commonly cited reason is the movement’s lack of concrete goals. While this may be a testament to Occupy’s organic, grassroots structure, it is a hindrance in the long run.

Until the Occupiers solve this problem, authorities will continue to trivialize the movement. And the damage done to public property – in this case, the buildings in Oakland – does little good for their image.

Occupy should not be working against the politicians or the police. Instead, it should be working with them. If Occupy touts itself as “the voice of the 99 percent,” shouldn’t that voice include police officers and local politicians as well?

Email Mirea at nmirea@media.ucla.edu. Send general comments to opinion@media.ucla.edu or tweet at us @DBopinion.


Join the discussion

You Should Know: Any comments posted on dailybruin.com may be printed in the Daily Bruin. the Daily Bruin reserves the right to remove any comment deemed racially derogatory, inflammatory, or spammatory. Repeat offenders may have their IP address banned from posting future comments. Please be nice.

If this is the first time you've commented, your comment won't appear until you've verified your email address.

Formatting Options:
  • Links: "my link":http://my.url.com
  • Bold: *something!*
  • Italic: _OMG!_

1 comment

First off, police officers and local politicians are enforcement apparatus of the 1%-controlled state, so no, anything that has any semi-legitimate claim to representing the interests of the 99% must stand firmly against them rather than engage in the milquetoast neoliberalism of offending nobody and standing substantively for nothing, and so making no progress whatsoever.
Secondly, how can you say O.O. used violence? Has property become animate—can it feel? Have we fetishized the material to the point where political property destruction—including the burning of a flag—is violence rather than political expression? The existence of private property is violent, at least in its current form that forces millions in America alone unnecessarily into extreme poverty, and causes between 10 and 25 (depending on your source) thousand people to die every day from easily preventable starvation; the attack of private property is an attack on a passively violent structure that oppresses virtually everyone, so is in itself a peaceful tactic.
Thirdly, you complete miss the points—both theoretical and factual—of this action. The Move-In Day is intended to reclaim an unused building supposedly for the public for true public use. The city was blocking O.O. from doing this—for another argument against the passive violence and class warfare inherent in the existence of private property, consider that there are more abandoned buildings than there are homeless people in America, and so the U.S. could freely end homelessness many times over tomorrow if it wanted to; the fact is, the U.S. does not want to end homelessness, or allow the use of abandoned buildings by people in need and/or with good intentions, which is why O.O. had to try to forcibly take the building. That building has been empty and unused for years, and is now still empty and unused—police power and taxpayer wealth were used to prevent that building from going to use at the expense of those who could and would use it, and those who worked to allow them to use it.
Your bias and mis-analysis astounds me. You are actively perpetuating mistruths and misrepresentations of a noble action to serve your neoliberal cause. You could easily be arguing for this if only you got your facts straight—the entire point of this action was that the city could and should allow the protesters to use the building to help others in need; the fact was that they actively and militaristically stood against this civic good. Get your facts (and logic) checked next time, you pathetic excuse for a reporter.

3:04 AM January 31, 2012, by Seth Newmeyer
Flag this comment
Advertisement
Featured classifieds »

ADLER WEINER RESEARCH is conducting a study with Male Juniors and Seniors This is a 2 part Study. You will be paid $25 for an 1-2 min video. Some people will be chosen for a follow-up interview on Friday, June 8th, which will pay $75 for 30 min. PLEASE EMAIL awfocusgroups@gmail.com WITH THE FOLLOWING INFORMATION...1. NAME2. AGE3. ETHNICITY4. WHAT YEAR ARE YOU IN? 5. PLEASE LIST WHAT YOU DO TO WORKOUT. 6. BEST DAY TIME TELEPHONE NUMBER!!! WE ARE ALSO ACCEPTING REFERRALS IF YOU HAVE FRIENDS THAT MIGHT QUALIFY, PLEASE PASS ALONG THIS INFORMATION. · 2200 - Research Subjects


CLINICAL RESEARCH COORDINATOR/MAXILLOFACIAL: Performing research on maxillofacial pain, Tempromandibular jaw dysfunction, atypical tooth pains, Atypical facial& headaches, bruxism, stress related jaw pains. Collect data, Identify protocol problems, inform investigators& assists in problem resolution efforts. Review patients record to find new treatment methods. Review proposed study protocols to evaluate factors, data management plans& potential subject risks. Send resume to: M.Heikali; F&M Radiology Medical Center Inc., 18065 Ventura Blvd, Encino, CA 91316 · 2200 - Research Subjects


C AND C++ INSTRUCTOR. SEEKING AN INTERN who is good at C and C++ coding. Ability to understand pre-written codes and explain to non-technical audience. Please specify the course/experience you had. The position will be all through summer and may be extended. The hours can be flexible. We pay $20 - 70/hr depends on experience. pls send your CV at yjpark09_1999@yahoo.com · 7800 - Help Wanted


CSO OFFICE ASSISTANTOffice Assistant needed to work flexible hours at the UCLA Police Dept./CSO Programs. Earn $9.37/hr. Must be a UCLA student w/at least one YR. remaining. Training provided for clerical duties. For details call (310) 825-5064. · 7800 - Help Wanted


RECEPTIONIST/SECRETARYWestside law firm seeking receptionist/secretary. Mon.- Fri. from 8:30 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. Ability to type from dictation and office experience not required, but preferred. Email resume with cover letter to joycparker@yahoo.com with title law office receptionist. · 7800 - Help Wanted


***For Sale- Luxury Condo 2B/2B 90024 - Close to UCLA www.decoratorcondo.com · 8750 - Condo/Townhouse for Sale

More multimedia »